|
Which infiltration method to use?
The double ring method was developed to measure infiltration without the loss of water by sideways movement (sorptivity) as happens from a single ring.
After 30 years experience in field measurement of infiltration, Soil Water Solutions has found that :-
a) It is nearly impossible to detect leaks between the inner and outer rings in a double ring system.
b) double rings take 4x as long to set up
c) the statistical error in the final field infiltration measurement is usually proportional to the total soil area tested
d) by using larger rings, the proportion of water lost to sideways movement is dramatically reduced (eg a 2cm sideways plume accounts for as much water as the ring if the ring is 10cm diam, but the same plume on a 40cm ring is only 10% of the total
Moral of the story : use the biggest ring you can manage in single ring configuration and do as many tests as you can in the time available. However, the down side is that you need a lot of water. If you are concerned about sideways water flow, then compare results from tests using a small (eg 20cm dia) ring and a 50cm diam ring - the results should give an indication if the side flow is a significant problem and some guide how to correct for it.
|